Rubberduck 2.1.x

The release was going to include a number of important fixes for the missing annotation/attribute inspection and quick-fix, but instead we disabled it, along with a few other buggy inspections, and pushed the release – 7 months after 2.0.13, the last release was now over 1,300 commits behind, and we were reaching a point where we knew a “green release” was imminent, but also a point where we were going to have to make some more changes to parts of the core – notably in order to implement the fixes for these broken annotation/attribute inspections.

So we shipped what we had, because we wouldn’t jeopardize the 2.1 release with parser logic changes at that point.

Crossroads

wooden_signpost_at_the_crossroads1
By Hillebrand Steve, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
So here we are, at the crossroads: with v2.1.0 released, things are going to snowball – there’s a lot on our plates, but we now have a solid base to build upon. Here’s what’s coming:

  • Castle Windsor IoC: hopefully-zero user-facing changes, we’re replacing good old Ninject with a new dependency injection framework in order to gain finer control over object destruction – we will end up correctly unloading!

That’s actually priority one: the port is currently under review on GitHub, and pays a fair amount of long-standing technical debt, especially with everything involving menus.

  • Annotation/Attributes: fixing these inspection, and the quick-fix that synchronizes annotations with module attributes and vice-versa, will finally expose VB module and member attributes to VBA code panes, using Rubberduck’s annotation syntax.

For example,  adding '@Description("This procedure does XYZ") on top of a procedure will tell Rubberduck that you mean that procedure to have a VB_Description attribute; when Rubberduck parses that module after you synchronize, it will be able to use that description in the context status bar, or as tooltips in the Code Explorer.

This is considered a serious issue, because it affects pretty much every single inspection. Luckily there’s a [rather annoying and not exactly acceptable] work-around (apply the fix bottom-to-top in a module), but still.

But there’s a Greater Picture, too.

The 2.1.x Cycle

At the end of this development cycle, Rubberduck will:

  • Work in the VB6 IDE;
  • Have formalized the notion of an experimental feature;
  • Have a working Extract Method refactoring;
  • Make you never want to use the VBE’s Project References dialog ever again;
  • Compute and report various code metrics, including cyclomatic complexity and nesting levels, and others (and yes, line count too);
  • Maybe analyze a number of execution paths and implement some of the coolest code inspections we could think of;
  • Be ready to get really, really serious about a tear-tab AvalonEdit code pane.

If all you’re seeing is Rubberduck’s version check, the next version you’ll be notified about will be 2.1.2, for which we’re shooting for 2017-11-13. If you want to try every build until then (or just a few), then you’ll want to keep an eye on our releases page!

Nothing to declare

Somewhere in the first batch of issues/to-do’s we created when we started Rubberduck on GitHub (Issue# 33 actually), there was the intention to create a tool that could locate undeclared variables, because even if you and I use Option Explicit and declare all our variables, we have brothers and sisters that have to deal with code bases that don’t.

So we tried… but Rubberduck simply couldn’t do this with the 1.x resolver: identifiers that couldn’t be resolved were countless, running an inspection that would pop a result for every single one of them would have crippled our poor little duckling… so we postponed it.

The 2.0 resolver however, thinks quite literally like VBA itself, and knows about all available types, members, globals, locals, events, enums and whatnot, not just in the VBA project, but also in every referenced COM library: if something returns a type other than Variant or Object, Rubberduck knows about it.

The role of the resolver is simple: while the parse tree of a module is being traversed, every time an identifier is encountered it attempts to determine which declaration is being referred to. If the resolver finds a corresponding declaration, an IdentifierReference is created and added to the Declaration instance. And when the resolver can’t resolve the identifier (i.e. locate the exact declaration the identifier is referring to), a null reference was returned and, unless you have detailed logging enabled, nothing notable happens.

As of the last build, instead of “doing nothing” when a reference to variable can’t be resolved to the declaration of that variable, we create a declaration on the spot: so the first appearance of a variable in an executable statement becomes the “declaration”.

We create an implicit Variant variable declaration to work with, and then this happens:

hhp2m

With a Declaration object for an undeclared variable, any further reference to the same implicit variable would simply resolve to that declaration – this means other Rubberduck features like find all references and refactor/rename can now be used with undeclared variables too.

Rubberduck is now seeing the whole picture, with or without Option Explicit.

The introduce local variable quick-fix simply inserts a “Dim VariableName As Variant” line immediately above the first use in the procedure, where VariableName is the unresolved identifier name. The variable is made an explicit Variant, …because there’s another inspection that could fire up a result if we added an implicit Variant.

The quick-fix doesn’t assume an indentation level – makes me wonder if we should run the indenter on the procedure after applying a quick-fix… but that’s another discussion.

To be continued…

Special Thanks to Rob Bovey and Stephen Bullen

Twitter is awesome: you share something with the world, and then the world shares something with you. Thanks to the awesomeness of Ross McLean, we are pleased to announce that Rubberduck 2.0 will include automagic indentation

…Powered by smart indenter

Yes! The original author and current maintainer of the magic indenting freeware tool downloaded by dozens of thousands of happy customers have kindly supplied us with the VB6 source code, and we’re going to put it to good use, port it to .NET, embed the almighty indentation algorithm into Rubberduck, and try to keep as much as possible of the formidable set of configuration settings that make Smart Indenter such a wonder.

To be continued…